
Artifacts and Emblems
—Todd
November 10
The Winter
Count
To
the Lakota Sioux, a year was called “a winter”— measured from first
snowfall to
first snowfall. Marking the passing of time and collecting the
important events
of a year for memory, they would record a “winter count.” Each year, or
events
within a year, would be remembered with a pictograph on an animal hide
showing
the crucial moments in tribal life. In the Carnegie Winter Count, for
instance,
“the year the stars fell” was the name and picture for the Leonid
meteor
showers of the year 1833. The Winter of Compassion was 1944, the year
of the
founding of The National Congress of
American Indians. Over a hundred original winter counts survive, and
can even
be seen online. (See: The
Winter Count.) Various schools
around
the
country are making their own winter counts in imitation of the native
American
tradition.
What
would an Adams School Winter Count look like? I asked the 4-5th
grade class, who are studying native Americans, to think of their own
winter
count after we looked at the Lakota example. You’ll have to imagine
their
responses as if accompanied by a drawing or image that complements
their
highlights. This will be the year of…the Red Sox, of course… “my baby
sister”…the arrival of Amber, my new cat…making igloos…skiing for the
first
time…the tsunami…hurricane Katrina.
Or, as one student pointed out, “disasters…and
help.”
The
winter count distills the meaning of events, threading singular moments
into a
tapestry that becomes the history of the tribe. Thanksgiving and New
Year’s
seem to be the common contemporary moments that come close to this
ritual. Here
we are, then, on the verge of the holiday which focuses us on gratitude
as we
look back, and anticipating the holiday that will focus us on looking
forward
with optimism and new purpose. One holiday asks, “How have we been
fortunate?”
and the other, “How will I make good
fortune?” If there is sincerity and humility attached, they are
questions that
also draw us out of ourselves to think of others: How have I; how will I, help others share in the
benefits that abound?
Any
“winter” is more than the sum of its parts, more than just an
enumeration of
the things that happened. Our tribe is certainly defined by more than
Red Sox
victory, little sisters joining the family, or nature’s turmoil. But
it’s still
good to count, particularly to affirm that we have a voice in
determining the
next winter count. Will this be another “Winter that strengthened our
Voices?”
“Winter of Shelter,” to cite a few of the Carnegie count winters. I
like the
activism in one of the short texts we’ve started using this fall as one
of our
morning pledges, because it distills
Anne
Lamott, a peerless inspirer of good writing, tells the story of her
brother,
age 10, agonizing over his science report on birds. “He’d had three
months to
write [it]. It was due the next day,” she writes. “He was at the
kitchen table
close to tears, surrounded by binder paper and pencils and unopened
books on
birds, immobilized by the hugeness of the task ahead. Then my father
sat down
beside him, put his arm around my brother’s shoulder, and said, ‘Bird
by bird,
buddy. Just take it bird by bird.’”*
We’ve all been there, either as the
report writer, the parent, or the teacher trying to coach and coax the
project
to completion. I remember my daughter
struggling with just such a report, an English assignment requiring her
to go
beyond a synopsis of the plot of April
Morning, to delve deeper than a mere summary of the list of
characters and
their actions. She had to step outside of her reading and writing
comfort zone.
A seventh grader, Hilary was in a fairly
typical, bumpy
transit from her competent, concrete summaries of the text to the
sub-textual
observations her teacher was training the class to do. The time had
come in her
growth as a reader and writer to explore the abstract sense of things,
the
figures in language. It was a painful struggle. It seemed to her like
an unfair
trick—words could be about something other than what they say. Go
figure!
“I can’t interpret
what happens.,” she moaned. “It just happens.
There’s no interpretation. It’s about what it’s about. That’s all there
is to
it!”
The parallel scene in my own schooling was also
seventh
grade, working long and hard one night to make the usual time-honored
book report
poster by pasting a collage of magazine photos on oak tag. Summarize
the plot,
illustrate the trials and tribulations of the characters in The
Outsiders, add a few photos clipped
from the newspaper—voila! Done.
When Mr. Katz returned my dutiful work, his
comment suggested that I
needed to interpret the story, think about “the why” of the story;
think about
the writer’s motivation in telling the story. Apparently, the story
meant
something other than what it said. The writer had been saying one thing
and
meaning another. It was about more than it was about. Go figure.
But what a thrill I felt in the subsequent
moment of
revelation when the “inner meanings” became clear to me and I left
behind the
illustrated book report (with fancy cover and huge titles) forever. A writer actually has control over this
stuff? A writer isn’t just recording the way it happened? The story is something imagined! I
realized. I took a giant leap towards critical examination of the craft
of
assembling words in a particular order for a particular reason.
We’re accustomed, of course, to a world that is
carelessly
worded. “It’s about…” is a constant refrain, as if meaning were
something
obvious, declarative, visible, agreed upon. And what Hilary was
encountering,
as we all do at some point, is the opening of the mind’s eye to the
more that’s
there. I don’t think even she thought it was just “about” a book report
in 7th
grade. The transition takes time, timing, and patience, like anything
learned.
What would Mr. Katz’s progress reports have said
about me,
I wonder? “In Language Arts, Todd is taking it ‘bird by bird.’” They’re
probably still filed away somewhere in my mother’s archive, and still
classified. Parent-teacher conferences? “Now, about his handwriting….”
Some
things haven’t changed.
—Todd
December 2
I also
thought back to the year I was in sixth grade. The teachers at my
school
organized a collection of used toys and clothing for low-income
families in
As
a classroom teacher in the
As
consumers of cultural messages, I fear we are becoming too accustomed
to
thinking only in terms of the grand gesture and generosity writ large.
Television would insist on “Extreme Makeovers,” or an “Angel Network”
required
to marshal resources that change desperate circumstances. Make no
mistake: my
admiration goes out to Oprah, and others, who use their media power and
personal wealth to bring attention and aid to people or areas in
extreme
need—oftentimes situations where no one
else will venture. But there is a veiled commercial ambition here
too,
harvesting attention for advertisers. At street level at
Al
got our boxes weighed and prepared for shipment in a jiffy. “Seven to
ten days,”
he said, referring to the time they’ll take in transit. We’ve already
heard
from the teachers in
—Todd
December 9
“Good
Morning. I’ll read a brief statement and then answer questions,” said
the
Commish, booming into his microphone.
“
The first reporter had his hands in
the air before the Commish had even begun reading his statement.
“Clarification, sir: Does this mean that you also can’t throw snowballs
on the
town Common?”
“—or how about on the playground
after school?” chimed in The American’s education correspondent.
“Let me amplify my statement.
Snowballs are not allowed during
Nonetheless, a sports reporter had
her hand in the air. “Does that mean no snowballs during basketball
practice,
or games at MMA? And is the Common owned by
The Commish considered this for a
second, then replied tersely, “Any Adams School-sponsored activity is
considered school time; no, the school does not own the Common.”
“Can I throw snowballs with my MMA
Big Brother,” asked the
“The ‘time’ and
‘location’ clauses apply to that one,” said the Commish.
“Commissioner, how about when the
older kids go downtown for lunch and are on
“Let me tell you a true story, my
friend,” intoned the Commish, leaning forward on his podium, dangling
his
glasses pendulously above the official league seal. “Last year we had a
little
incident with snowballs flying en route to the Variety. I had instant
messages
from the neighbors, faster than you can say “Slush Puppy,” as soon as
the first
ball was airborne, informing me that a few of our ‘franchise players’
were
wreaking havoc. Furthermore, you could
be on the flying bridge of the State of
The questions persisted. No stone
would be left unturned. “Let’s say you and a friend agree that it’s
okay to
throw snow at one another?” probed the court reporter for Entertainment
Tonight.
“Automatic third felony strike,”
said the Commish. “Burnt toast.”
“What if we’re wearing snowpants and
jackets?” asked the style editor for
“Irrelevant,”
said the Commish. “You’re French toast.”
“Could you be more specific about
the consequences for throwing snowballs?” asked the crime reporter for
The
Patriot.
The Commish rattled off the
sanctions: “Seven game suspension; fine; media shame; mandatory
ineligibility
for Winter Four Square Hall of Fame.”
There was a last, lone hand still
raised. “Can I throw snowballs at my
house?” said the
cub reporter.
“Sure, kid,” said the Commish, “But
it depends on your definition of ‘at.’ That’s a non-league venue. Ask
your
parents. Have a ball. We all done here?”
“One more, sir: What do you think of
the dodge ball salary cap?”
But no one
waited for the answer. The press corps bolted out the door, eager to
file their
stories before the next news cycle.
—Todd
December 16
BTUs,
Student Age, and
Academic Subjects: Notes towards a new
theory of elementary school heating.
The school
building
is cold—again. That is, the rest of the building is cold. My
office and
Barb Thomas’s office are saunas. But Bill McWeeny’s room is
glacial
(yesterday it was a sauna); so is the art room. We expect the lobby to
be cold,
given the constant traipsing in and out during the day, and the doors
that
leak. So I scout the other classrooms and test the little white control
dials
on the radiators: open. “Control,” however, is a misnomer! The pipes
are hot,
but the rooms are cold. The thermostats on the walls are vestiges of
the old system
and do nothing.
The “new” system is
rapidly becoming an old system
and the subject of much analysis. Circulator pumps working? Check.
Burner
going? Check. Supply valves open to the radiators? Check. Then why’s it
so
cold? Eighth graders start showing up in my office wearing parkas and
looking
for BTUs—no room here, alas. Poor Elaine Bertrand is teaching her three
math
groups in the lobby wearing gloves. I call
Rusty arrives promptly
with his bucket of wrenches to
check on today’s frigid conditions, and heads straight to Bill’s room
and the
control knob by the backdoor. Our conversation turns to drafts and
unheated
spaces and insulation for the basement. Perhaps an external wood-fired
furnace
would help? There are alternatives to oil-fired burners, but at what
cost.
Pay-back ratios and the geo-political fuel nexus filter into the
discussion of
how to keep
“I try and get the big
kids or larger groups down
here first thing in the morning,” she said, leaning against the
radiator in the
art room. “They produce a lot more heat.”
I should have known.
The solution is not unlike the
Paul Manning Ice Cream/calorie Coefficient: “the colder the ice cream,
the more
calories are burned off while consuming it.” Therefore, the colder the
ice
cream the more you can eat because the process of consuming it counters
the
effect of the high caloric intake. Simple. Patrons of the Castine
Variety have
known this for years. Therefore, Nelson’s Elementary School Heating
Coefficient
Hypothesis goes like this: The colder the building, the harder you need
to
study to burn the calories necessary to heat the building.
Now the question is,
which subjects produce the most
BTUs, factoring for age and body mass. Since no two learners are alike,
I’m
guessing that the answer will be “your favorite subject.” Thus,
multiple
intelligences and learning styles are automatically factored in. Here’s
the
good news:
My research suggests that our art room
full of ten or
so enthusiastic second and third graders weaving yarn tapestries, for
example,
produces sufficient BTUs to heat 120% of that space. Fifth graders
doing
multiplication facts produce even more heat. Six, seventh and eighth
graders,
factoring for greater mass and more complex brain activity, produce so
much
heat that were it electricity we could sell it back to the CMP grid.
And we’re just a little elementary school. Who knew that the
education
system in this country was sitting atop a latent energy reserve greater
than
the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge!
The technical equation
is as follows: W=(S/m)(C/T),
where W is warmth, S is number of students over mass, C is curriculum
and T is
duration of activity. Here’s a simpler way to describe the phenomenon:
Desire
to learn is heat. Clearly, we will leave no child behind in a chilly
classroom….and keep the ice cream good and cold.
—Todd
Where
does all that water go? The fire
department delivers another 1,000 gallons to our small ice rink behind
the
school, but it still doesn’t look full—except for the eight inches in
the “deep
end.” We have a “coast line,” where
The hole in the corner
of the deep
end, six inches up the side, was certainly one explanation for our
apparent
loss. Denny found that on Monday and plugged it (we think) so that we
weren’t
losing quite so much water as we were adding. So now that we have our
“fingers”
in the dike, it should be filling up fast. But the “shallow” end still
doesn’t
have ice covering all of the plastic liner. What’s going on under
the ice and plastic?
As a younger student
and I gazed at
the freezing progress on Tuesday morning, he suggested we put more
water in the
shallow end, not just the deep end. Hmmm. How would Piaget explain this
one?
Now it’s not just an interesting science experiment, it’s an experiment
in
childhood cognition: conservation of ice rink mass. Now factor for age,
powers
of observation, experience with various size cups of water.
“Well, the shallow end
won’t fill
up until the deep end is full,” I say. “Actually, the water is going to
find
the lowest point no matter where you pour it in.” Shallow and deep are
tough
concepts when talking about an apparently level surface.
“Oh.” Pause. “Then put
more water
in the shallow end,” he says. I will—via the deep, downhill end.
At morning meeting,
after the slide
show of the fire department unloading the water the day before, it’s
time for
the progress report.
“Here’s
where we stand,” I explain. “1,000 gallons of water went in yesterday
(thank
you Castine Fire Department), but some of it leaked out. And we can’t
see what
might be happening under the existing ice. If there’s a hole there, we
won’t
know. And it was warm and sunny yesterday. So we probably melted some
of our
ice for the sake of adding more water. What we really need is deep cold.”
Why is deep,
old-time cold so hard
to come by? A hundred years ago, there was a thriving ice trade on this
peninsula. From big rivers to small ponds, ice was harvested once it
reached a
thickness of twelve inches. Then it was packed in sawdust in icehouses
for up
to a year, before being shipped by sail to all parts of the world. From
After
morning meeting Tom Gutow and I walk out back and check on the rink and
the
Snoopy knew
the answer: Why is it a chore to
shovel snow off the driveway, but clearing snow off the skating rink
(or four-square
court, or removing snow for fort building) is a pleasure?
On Monday,
for instance, four kindergartners
were eagerly clearing a mere dusting of snow off of our basketball
court. They
were doing quite nicely with only a couple of sticks that had been
converted
into “plows.” When I offered them shovels, they got a special gleam in
their
eyes: tool time. It was a promotion. Three shovels were fetched in
short order
and the team went to work. Real tools make it real work. This is “The
Zamboni
Factor.”
Kids actually
compete for the chance to clear
snow off of any prime play surface. And who hasn’t shared Snoopy’s
fascination
with the big machine that resurfaces the hockey rink? No game can take
place
until the zamboni has prepared the way, which means the zamboni driver
is the man. In some ways it’s a more
inviting role than playing goalie or center forward. On our elementary
level,
everyone wants to take the beveled shovel and walk back and forth
across any
piece of ice, methodically clearing the surface for the waiting
players. The
shovel driver is the man.
Part of the
principal at work is the fact that
snow removal is a chore, while
“zamboni/shovel” driving is a job. It’s
official work, a service, practically requiring a uniform, training,
and
full-fledged union membership. It is a role on which others depend,
and, of
course, involves specialized equipment. Being the man, versus working
for the
man. I see a correspondence therein to many of life’s little tasks. It
extends
beyond snow removal and ice resurfacing.
The
professional literature on the zamboni
factor contains several sub-categories that may sound familiar to Adams
Schoolers. Research shows, for instance,
why running the vacuum cleaner and helping with the dishes in the
school
kitchen are such attractive jobs (note: not
chores). Even students who hide under their beds at the slightest
parental
suggestion to vacuum their bedrooms are the first to volunteer when
classroom
mess requires a canister vacuum cleaner operator. Students who suddenly
claim
mountains of homework more pressing than doing the dishes at home jump
for the
yellow gloves when Brenda needs assistants after lunch service in the
school
kitchen. There may be more to it than wearing the official yellow
rubber
gloves.
The zamboni
factor is more than some sleight of
hand that gives profound meaning to ordinary tasks. The power isn’t
just in the
tool. I think it signifies the meaning we seek in tasks,
the link between good work and good works: taking pride in
the work we do, and being offered work that feels valued. Sometimes,
for young
workers like our students, it simply means tweaking the perception of
work by a
few degrees to create a job. One
could learn about physics and the laws of gravity by studying equations
on
paper. But how much better to set up an incline plane in Mr. McWeeny’s
classroom and start the NASCAR of marble runs. (Better yet: an
Once the ice rink out
back is
frozen good and solid, we’ll see more zamboni drivers at work. It never
fails.
It’s good work, if you can get it. Good jobs attract good workers, and
we’ve
got ‘em. And no one plays while the person driving the “zamboni” is
getting an
important job done. Huzzah for the zamboni drivers!
It snuck up on me: suddenly the
halfway point of the school year is upon us. Next Wednesday is the
87-and-a-halfth day in the calendar, and, at
We’re still
filling up, and this apparent
defiance of the laws of physics is more than a trick of the mind. Even
though
the second half of a school year can feel like the downhill slope,
hurtling
towards June, time passes in unique ways. The external benchmarks of
calendars
and schedules only describe one kind of time passage. The second half
is more
like two thirds of the year in terms of the learning we can pour in.
Better to
focus on the upcoming tipping points, to use a popular phrase, which
are
internal, less predictable, and indicators of more profound growth.
“The goal
is soul,” as Bono says, and the good thing about going downhill isn’t
just the
speed—it’s the momentum.
Here’s a tipping point. A child
enters, say, fifth grade long before they truly become
a fifth grader. Fully
inhabiting any new grade takes a while. There are new routines to
master, a new
teacher and classmates to know, new curriculums and traditions to
practice. But
those are just the quantifiable parts. A tipping point comes when we
move
beyond mere format to fully inhabit
the grade with a new sense of self, of accomplishment, of our
individual
capacities, and possibilities. It’s tipping from being in
fifth grade to being a
fifth grader.
Perhaps we’re accustomed to thinking
of tipping points as large-scale phenomena, the moments when a grand
new
cultural idea, trend, or behavior suddenly subsumes the status
quo. But a tipping point is about subtleties. There are, in
fact, many tipping points in a school year. It can be the ‘Aha!’ moment
when
the concept of multiplication becomes clear, or when words take flight
and a
poem’s “deep inner meaning” finally makes sense. Suddenly you can play
C sharp
on your trumpet, and a whole tune falls into place, or the short vowel
sound
you hear finally corresponds to the letter you’re seeing in the middle
of
words. You walk to school alone, or score your first basketball points,
launching an NBA career from our little coastal league. Just raising
your hand
in morning meeting for the first time is a big moment. These might be
tipping
points within tipping points. Even The Tipping Point, Malcolm Gladwell’s
book that launched the concept, must have had a tipping point!
Beware: Tipping points arrive
spontaneously
and without warning. It’s good to be on the look out though. We may be
halfway
“there,” with a couple more halves to go before June, but we make more
progress
in the time allotted if we celebrate those new trumpet notes (play ‘em
loud!)
and vowels and consonant blends (“One good word is worth a thousand
pictures”)
and reports of nature and birthdays in morning meeting. We can’t always
see
them coming, or recognize that “we’re there” until much later. But
we’re
destined to be “more than the sum of our parts” if we take delight in
the
surprising “tips” ahead, and savor the momentum they bring.
—Todd
January 20
Last week, we
had a guest chef for pizza day. He
opened a new restaurant out back and needed to hire some employees.
There was
an overwhelming response! By lunchtime, delivery personnel were taking
Nellie’s
Deli products around the building to teacher customers, and after lunch
a
scullery crew had the clean-up done in record time.
The job
application even had some merit as a
survey. Since the answers to a few of the questions are not bound by
confidentiality, we can share them here. School pizza, for instance, is
more
popular than Ernie’s or Zeke’s,
though the dog and pinball machine at Zeke’s were notable attractions,
and the
cooling down time between the Variety and home was significant to many
customers. Popular references included several pets, and characters
from
fiction (the Pink Panther, Mrs. Frisby). Pepperoni wins hands down for
favorite
kind of pizza; scrambled, for eggs any style; crusts: yes; hairnets:
not so
popular. Availability to start work? “
Still needed:
cashiers, waiters, servers, a sous chef, line cooks,
and a maitre d’ for all shifts. Interviews are
pending. Background checks are under way. Can a daily amuse-bouche be far
behind?
Application for
Employment
Please fill out this
application in your own handwriting and send to:
c/o
—Todd
Proprietor and chief bottle-washer
Nellie’s Deli
January 27
Flash Nebula
is in
the house!
Judging by
the mountain of colorful fabric
scraps on the art room table, I knew something wonderful was underway
in second
grade art.
“What are
you guys making?” I inquired.
“Finger
puppets,” was the gleeful reply, as five hands shot in the air with the
works
in progress stuck on forefingers and thumbs.
On one hand was “my
mom,” on
another were superheroes in the making. A good superhero needs two
things: a
cool name, and an arch nemesis. Dustin had the name: “This is Flash
Nebula.” He
wasn’t sure about the arch nemesis. (Footnote: Have you ever heard of a
nemesis
that wasn’t arch? Aren’t all moms superheroes?)
An hour later, the first graders
were in the art room and modeling clay dragons were taking shape.
Casey’s was
called Rory. “This is the dragon of death,” said Hannah, as she
displayed her
winged creature with scales reminiscent of her beloved triceratops.
Plasticine
meets Pleistocene.
In the last week, I’ve had a number
of conversations among faculty members talking about the raw materials
of play
and learning. Mrs. P’s class was making bamboo on Friday, using
newspaper rolls
held together with masking tape and painting them a vivid bamboo green.
By
Wednesday a rain forest was growing in her room—a background tableau on
which
to pin information about monkeys and snakes and other rain forest flora
and
fauna. Data meets dada, or “imaginary gardens with real toads in them,”
as
Marianne Moore defined poetry. If we simply turned the kids loose with
a pile
of scrap wood, they’d make incredible things, Ms. P and I mused.
Across the
hall, flights to Mars and Pluto are taking shape, as Mrs. Lameyer’s
class travels
the solar system in search of knowledge, having built rockets to get
there from
here. Byron proudly displayed his rocket ship, complete with flaming
tissue
paper coming out of the business end of the Saturn booster. On Wednesday, the class made comets out of
Styrofoam and silver sparkles. I trust they can also explain the orbits
and
composition of the real thing.
Last week
we talked about how long it will take NASA’s New Horizons rocket to
reach
Pluto, 3 billion miles away. “Make a note to check up on it when you’re
in high
school,” I suggested. “That’s when the pictures will start coming back
to earth
and you’ll see them.” Sometimes learning feels like looking through the
wrong
end of the telescope! The payoff can require billions of miles of
travel, or
years of waiting. Perhaps Flash Nebula
will be the first earthling on Pluto?
I’ve always liked
Howard Nemerov’s
enigmatic poetic take on such learning. It’s easy to skate along on its
surface
whimsy without fully inspecting what it affirms about the possibilities
we
should invite at school, lest we become too absorbed with the data in
our
lives.
The
world is full of mostly invisible things,
And
there is no way but putting the mind’s eye,
Or
its nose, in a book, to find them out,
Things
like the square root of Everest
Or
how many times Byron goes into
Or
whether the law of the excluded middle
Applies
west of the
Most of the ingenuity,
pleasure,
and richness of a school day arrive from the moments when Flash Nebula
appears
and vanquishes his arch nemesis, Data Magneto.
Both are in the building—and they kind of need one another, in
the way
all superheroes need a nemesis. Be on the lookout. Stand back, citizens!
—Todd
February 3
In some ways, the name
says it all.
Without having seen one, can you conjure an image of what an Araboolie
must look
like?* Well, good! Does it go something like this…When an Araboolie
wakes up
each morning, they never know what color their skin or hair will be.
They are
definitely from “away”—an undisclosed exotic island.
You’ll meet the
Araboolies and
their menagerie on April 11 at
“The Araboolies
weren’t the neatest
people in the world, truth to tell, but they sure knew how to have
fun,” writes
Swope. “They put their furniture all over the yard and lived
outside—they
played outside, ate outside and watched TV outside. The Araboolies even
slept
outside, all cuddled up like puppies in the largest bed you ever saw.
They
snored like crazy.” They’re different, and that’s the fun of being an
Araboolie. Why settle for being the same color two days in a row.
Free-spirited
Araboolie life is about change, spontaneity, and vibrancy.
The Araboolies
have a wok, plant palm trees, and have exotic pets like a wild
barumpuss and a
popalok. They play Boolanoola ball, which you’d almost think was
four-square,
except for the obligatory ululation, dancing, and recitation of state
and
foreign capitols. They have palm trees in the kitchen and talk and sing
with
their hands. Their musical theme sounds like calypso-reggae, with an
emphasis
on percussion.
However,
not everybody likes “different.” When someone says, “You look like an
Araboolie,” is it an insult, or a compliment? When the Araboolies
arrive in
town, they’re not entirely popular with a certain Mr. and Mrs. Pinch.
Young
Joy, on the other hand, likes her new next-door neighbors—but there’s a
potential cost. Some kids aren’t so sure about their outrageous styles
and
games. We also discover that there might just be a little Araboolie,
and Pinch,
in us all. The sub-plots suggest that some of the adults in town have
prior
Araboolie experiences.
We hope the
play will
let us explore acceptance of diversity, respect, and tolerance. It’ll
also be a
great excuse for a conga line dance, wild hair colors and zany
costumes, and
some cool sets. The Araboolies just might have some good ideas for our
own
Mardi Gras parade. So, send in the Araboolies! (Don’t bother—we’re
here.)
—Todd
February 10
One of my
favorite Olympic success stories is about a big loser.
During
the Albertville Winter Olympics in 1992, I was inspired by a Moroccan
cross-country skier.
At
the start of the race, the Moroccan simply stepped aside and allowed
the
fiercer medal contenders to pass him by. He then skied his best.
Although he
finished the course hours after The Terminator, he won “his race.”
Perhaps he
didn’t belong in competition at the Olympic level, or deserve the label
“Olympic athlete,” but I have to admire his tenacity and gumption.
The front pages of Olympic reporting this week were full
of figure skater Michelle Kwan’s agonizing story. The five-time world
champion
pulled out of gold medal contention at the Turin Olympics over the
weekend, due
to injury—a move that made room for younger contenders on the
Did
you also notice the back page story about Anne Abernathy, the
50-something
woman competing in the luge in her sixth winter Olympics? Known as
“Grandma
Luge,” she hails from the
The
Moroccan skier and grandma luger from the tropics are good
object-lessons for
kids—as important a role model as The Terminator or Bode Miller and
other medal
contenders or winners—because they exemplify an accurate sense of their
abilities,
self-denial, and perseverance in the face of adversity. These are the
great
qualities of Olympians regardless of their medals. This is the Olympic
mettle
that anyone can win.
You can win an Olympic medal by crossing the finish line
first, by being judged best, or by being overly hyped, media attention
being an
embedded part of the contest in most sports these days. (Cf. The recent
“that’s
just Bode being Bode” media jag). But two things stand out that might
relate to
a positive message for kids. You need to compete at the right level,
both in
order to win and in order for the challenge to be fair. And you need to
ski, or
luge, or skate “your own race.” In this
regard, you win just by competing. It’s how you develop intellectual
“muscle”
and medal caliber performances.
To
push the point a little further, a quality education gradually raises a
child’s
expectation for what they can accomplish, providing them the feedback
that
develops self-judgment. This should involve both familiar and
unfamiliar experiences,
which will lead to resiliency: each child’s durable sense that he or
she is a
powerful learner and capable of coping with the unknown. Teachers want
to
inspire lofty personal goals without creating unfair competition with a personally inappropriate
lofty ideal. We have to be sure that kids are learning how to “play
their own
game,” and that the expectations they create for themselves are ones
they truly
value and can achieve—i.e. the right muscles for their “sport!”
As
to the media hype: maybe some day our culture will mature and realize
that
there is such a thing as bad
publicity, especially to an audience of future Olympians.
“If you have to ask,
I can’t tell you.”
As I watched an eighth
grader give
a power point presentation on Louis Armstrong the other day—the older
kids are
studying Jazz (New Orleans, in particular) with Bill Schubeck—I was
reminded of
his famous quote. Responding to a request to “define jazz,” Satchmo
said: “If
you have to ask, I can’t tell you.”
Some things
can’t be taught. You can have great chops on your instrument— music
theory,
technical skill, even experience—and still not play Jazz.
It’s “about” more than playing the right notes in the right
order. There’s something between the notes; something not recorded in
the sheet
music, like the gestalt of a poem.
Something the instrument maker, bandleader, music teacher, and even the
player
himself didn’t plan. Jazz just happens when the conditions are right,
when the
tune is more than the sum of its parts.
Jazz might be a good emblem for creativity in lots of
areas. It defies definition, is difficult or impossible to actually
teach, but
yields such rich rewards. You know it when you see it, hear it, feel
it, touch
it—or when it touches you.
Creativity swings. And maybe we
can’t define it, but there is a way to encourage it and make room for
it. In
fact, that may be all we can do.
You can’t
rehearse
an improvisation, but you can practice in order to improvise—that’s
getting
your chops. True improvisation just happens when inspiration, timing,
and technique
magically converge and you get jazz…or poetry, or art, or science, or
home
runs. This made me think about the daily teaching choices we make
regarding
practice versus improvisation.
As
students we’ve all paid our dues learning the “scales” that allow us to
make
our own music, whether it’s the rudiments of the piano, the periodic
tables,
verb conjugations, or figure drawing exercises. As parents or educators
we are
in the business of teaching how to practice various intellectual
disciplines,
creativity and independence of the student being our goal. But it’s
essential
to define the continuum that keeps us true to our goal; otherwise we
end up
with just scales.
For
instance, are our students independent enough to answer these questions
about
their own learning continuum: Are we just trying to read the words, or
really
understand, the book? Is the point of the assignment to write two
pages, or to
write an essay, or story? Are we
merely running on schedule, or
creating time for ingenuity and delight? What is the nature of the test
for
which we are teaching? What is the meaning of a “good” grade? The
answers are
important. They define an interior, core value related to creativity
and
learning.
Last week, an article
in Education Week (
I’ve come to think that we should
think of creativity less as a free-spirited, undisciplined part of our
lives (a
bad habit), and more as a kind of vital skill: the ability to solve
problems. In fact, it may be the most
important kind of problem solving
we practice because it’s what we use to cope with uncertainty,
unfamiliar
tasks, and new situations. Creativity is flexibility, improvisation,
adaptivity, resilience…jazz.
Sternberg also points
out that we
ought to make a place for it. “The main
things that
promote the habit are (a) opportunities to engage in it, (b)
encouragement when
people avail themselves of these opportunities, and (c) rewards when
people
respond to such encouragement and think and behave creatively,” he
writes. “You
need all three. Take away the opportunities, encouragement, or rewards,
and you
will take away the creativity. In this respect, creativity is no
different from
any other habit, good or bad.”
Perhaps
we can’t define creativity, but knowing the conditions that encourage
it helps.
Like astrophysicists, perhaps we can detect it by observing the
behavior of the
particles orbiting the atomic nucleus! Questions are good detectors.
Are we
taking pleasure in the journey? Have we preserved time for
contemplation? Do we
emphasize joy and humor? Are we allowing ourselves the chance to stop
and play,
time to improvise? Most importantly, are we using appropriate measures
of our
success? Popularity, cost, location, size, standardized test scores
aren’t
always the most accurate predictors of value. As another band leader
said, “It
don’t mean a thing if it ain’t got that swing.”
Creativity
may be
hard to define—“If you have to ask, I can’t tell”—but it’s easy to feel
its
effects. Only time will tell if we’re developing it here. It’s a wait
and see
proposition, but the particles are definitely in excited orbits. Fulfilling lives—that’s the long-term harmony
we’re looking
for.
—Todd
March 3
It’s
no accident that NASCAR chose this week to announce
Pit
row for the race, held at
“It took us a long time to get everything tuned just
right,” says Macomber, as he applied a torque wrench to the vibration
over-ride
sensor on his sleek ride.
“We found that when we turned the radio up to 11, we got
the best velocity, acceleration and momentum,” added Olivari, though he
declined to say which classic rock station yielded the best
performance. “Can’t
give away our edge,” he said.
The
M-O car, a black and red wedge with the famous Stones tongue logo on
the hood,
is also known for its drag-reducing paint, a special ion transducing
epoxy-based turbine-dried chemical compound on which the team is
seeking a
patent. “Our lips are sealed,” said the racing partners, when asked for
particulars, but they vowed an 8 second victory—with a $3 million price
tag.
Proprietary paint jobs are not the only news this year at
CASTVAMP, as the race is known to the G car faithful. Race car
fine-tuning is a
lonely, secretive art, and crew chiefs are reluctant to even
inadvertently
relay their innovative technology or practices. However, an experienced
observer will notice many an interesting gadget in this year’s cars.
There
are the mid-car quarter weight consoles; various drag-reducing waxes
and
compounds; graphite and oil injection suspension systems; slant front
or curved
back airfoils on the custom body shapes; and even front end tube
stabilizers,
to say nothing of technologies hidden under the hood. One car is
rumored to
have a cellulose nucleus alignment capacitor, the latest in fiber-based
body
structure strength theory. To reduce friction, the Squirt car has only
two wheels
touching at a time.
&nb